Daily prompt: Who decides?


Once upon a time, the People of Earth were in a bit of a mess. Lots of lust and covetousness, lots of lying and cheating…

I say once upon a time, but really, this particular time was once of many times both before and after the event of which I speak, but we’ll get to that in a minute.

On this particular occasion, so the story goes, one old bloke thought enough is enough (as you do),took himself up a mountain to think about it, and came back with two stone tablets on which were written a list of rules that would keep the People on the straight and narrow.

Needless to say, there was a lot of toing and froing about this (who really wants to give up their lust and covetousness, let alone their golden calves) during which the tablets got broken and had to be rewritten, but in the end the old bloke convinced them that the rules were the Word of God and the people agreed to obey them. (There’s nothing like the threat of being struck down to make you straighten up and fly right.)

But unfortunately, the People of Earth have short memories in the context of the millennia, their baser natures are deplorably resilient, and perhaps worst of all, they have a fanatical attachment to being Right. So once the old bloke was no longer around to interpret and neither was the Messiah  who followed some time later, the People of Earth got stuck into what some declared was a myth and some swore blind was the Absolute Truth and embarked on a battle that continues to this day.

As a fence-sitter in this particular battle, what I find most disturbing about it is the rabidly intolerant factionalism among those who purport to be on the same side: the Absolute Truth supporters. Each faction insists (quite stridently, in some cases) that they and they alone are the proponents of the Absolute Truth, that they and they alone are the true interpreters of The Word, and no other faction will be saved come the Apocalypse.

Which logically speaking (if I might use logic on such a delicate matter) is questionable at the very least given that The Word was transcribed more than two thousand years ago, by men relying on their memories of events that had come to pass a long time before that.  Furthermore, it has been interpreted and reinterpreted from interpretations so many times – linguistically, philosophically and theologically –  that any claims to one definitive truth that negates all others has a definite hotline-to-god ring about it that I find just a tiny bit arrogant.

Because what I am sure of (here on my fence) is that the People of Earth are still in a mess, that believers and non-believers are equally messy, and that telling people they’re damned is not helpful.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Daily prompt: Who decides?

  1. angloswiss says:

    Yesss I enyoyed that one, I wonder what the people will believe after the next 2000 years if there is stll an earth

    • Stephen Hawking says we’ve only got another 1000 years on this planet, so perhaps it won’t matter. But people being as they are, I’m sure the factions will still exist, and they’ll find something to believe in that they consider raises them above lesser mortals.

  2. AprilEsutton says:

    Yes we are, an absolute mess indeed!

  3. All that was on those tablets was simple good sense for building a society. All good advice. Turning it into SIN, however, that was a big mistake (IMO).

  4. Hopefully there will still be an earth in 2,000 years and hopefully we won’t be on it to pollute it any more. I wish I could believe we had a future but sadly I see no evidence.

    • I’m rapidly approaching the point of thinking our demise won’t even be sad. Human nature is becoming so ugly and self-absorbed it might be good to wipe it out and start again. Makes me glad I’m old, with more years behind me than ahead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s